Archive for the ‘Consumer Credit’ Category

Anyone else’s credit score drop after submitting a dispute?

Saturday, April 9th, 2011

I wanted to put this out here in addition to the blog I posted earlier about Equifax lowering my credit score every time I submit a dispute. You can find that post here: http://www.newworld.ws/blog/2011/03/23/equifax-will-lower-your-credit-score-when-you-submit-a-dispute/

I monitor the traffic to my website and monitor the search terms people use to find my website.  I see that a lot of other people have also been searching for information regarding Equifax credit scores dropping while a credit item is being disputed on their credit report.  So if you happen to find this blog and the same thing happened to you, will you please share your experience here or in the other post (link above).  I would really like to know if this is happening to a lot of people.  If it is and everyone shares their experiences, maybe we can do something about it. 

Also, has anyone else noticed if TransUnion or Experian do this too?  I do not have score monitoring for them.

I did file a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission.  I think everyone else should do the same.

Some people might not think it’s a big deal if they drop your score during a dispute since the dispute only takes up to 45 days.  But here is why it’s a problem…

I was in the market to buy a new car.  I had a small and very old collection account on my Equifax credit report.  I wanted to try to get it removed before I bought the car.  I noticed immediately after the dispute that my credit score dropped.  Nothing else had changed on my credit report except they changed the comment section to “investigation in progress”.  The dispute was taking too long and there was a car I was in love with so I decided to try to get it then instead of waiting for the dispute to complete.

I imagine that there would be many situations where an unsuspecting consumer might dispute several items, then need to apply for some sort of credit shortly after, and be denied credit because their score was drastically reduced.  I want to point out that it’s never just a few points… it’s a lot!

So anyway, if you have experienced this… please share your story with everyone.  Thanks so much!

Equifax will lower your credit score when you submit a dispute!

Wednesday, March 23rd, 2011

I have been a member of Equifax Credit Monitoring, Score Watch, and ID Patrol for many years now.  I have noticed something over the last year that I feel is very unfair and unacceptable. 

I have been doing a lot to repair my credit and periodically have to dispute items on my credit report to get them removed or updated.  Any time I submit a dispute, I have noticed that my credit score drops by 10 points within 24 hours of submitting my dispute.  This happens every time, without fail.  My score does not go back up until the dispute is complete.  Some times that takes 45 days. 

So what if I need to apply for a loan or something within that 45 days?  This seems like unfair practice to me.  I feel as though they are punishing users like myself for doing what we are legally entitled to do.  I am going to have to look into this further. 

Can anyone else confirm this?

—EDIT—

I posted a second blog about this here: http://www.newworld.ws/blog/2011/04/09/anyone-elses-credit-score-drop-after-submitting-a-dispute/

Unfair Credit Bureau Scoring

Friday, September 11th, 2009

It’s so clear to me that the 3 consumer credit bureau’s reporting systems are totally unfair and flawed.  I can’t believe we are still using them as they are and that more hasn’t been done to ensure the accuracy and fairness of their reporting.

My husband has absolutely nothing bad on his credit.  Never has.  He established it for the first time about 2 years ago.  He has a Capital One credit card ($500) limit, a small unsecured loan through CitiFinancial, and a small secured loan through BMI credit union.  He had a second secured motorcycle loan with BMI which we paid off a few days ago because we sold it.  When he got his last loan his score was 620.  Now it’s all the way down to 587.  The only negative factor is the percentage of debt to credit, but he has never gone over his limits.  He has never been late on a payment either.

So when we paid off that secured BMI loan, we had plans to borrow a new unsecured loan for the same amount as the one we paid off.  This was so we could get me a new laptop for work.  BMI proceeds to tell us his score dropped since the time we opened the secured loan and he no longer qualifies for an unsecure loan.  How is this fair when he has paid off a loan with them for the same amount we want to borrow back and has demonstrated great credit management skills??

Now get this…

In all honesty, I have a bunch of old collections, tax liens I am trying to pay off, and my debt/credit ratio is bad… yet my score is higher then his.  Only because I have had more loans open for longer.  I’m sorry, but that just isn’t fair at all.  I’m sure that if you were able to compare people’s credit reports side by side from all walks of life, you would see that there is nothing just or fair about how they are scoring people.